Refusal to assess (appealing the decision)

This page is for parents and carers considering appealing a local authority decision not to carry out an Education, Health & Care (EHC) needs assessment for your child/young person.

The decision letter from the local authority will explain your right to mediation and appeal. (You cannot appeal a refusal to assess decision where the local authority has carried out an EHC needs assessment in the previous six months).

Firstly, It's important to fully understand why the local authority reached this decision. This will help you decide whether to appeal and, should you decide to, will be key when building your case.

Before appealing you must firstly consider mediation, this can be really useful for example, where you have some additional information or a new report you would like to share with the local authority. It is possible that with new information the local authority will agree to reconsider their decision - and may avoid an appeal.

Read about mediation

 

Is this my only opportunity to appeal?

You should not feel pressured to appeal as you may re-request an Education, Health and Care needs assessment at a later date, allowing time for further strategies or support to be tried.

Click to download our leaflet

The Children & Families Act 2014 says:

"The local authority must secure an EHC needs assessment for the child or young person if, after having regard to any views expressed and evidence submitted under subsection (7), the authority is of the opinion that:

(a) the child or young person has or may have special educational needs, and

(b) it may be necessary for special educational provision to be made for the child or young person in accordance with an EHC plan." (36.8)

So what does this mean?

Your case needs to satisfy these two conditions (known as the legal tests) in order for a successful outcome. The important thing to note here is the use of the word 'may' in both these tests - the child 'may' have SEN and 'may' need an EHC plan.

Usually the first of these (a) is not in dispute and the local authority will likely be relying on the second (b) of these legal tests.

However, if you are uncertain as to whether your child has SEN, take a look at the definition explained on our homepage.

You do not need to evidence that your child/young person definitely needs an EHC plan. The purpose of this type of appeal is to establish whether the local authority should carry out an EHC needs assessment.

You can register an appeal, either within two months of the original decision being sent by the local authority, or within one month of receiving the mediation certificate whichever is the later. 

You will need to send:

  • your decision letter from the local authority
  • your signed mediation certificate
  • your reasons for appeal
  • completed, signed form 35a*

Your appeal reasons and supporting evidence can be submitted at this stage, but you can send in further information at a later date. However, check your paperwork from SEND Tribunal carefully as there are strict submission deadlines within this legal process.

Download the SEND Tribunal guide 'How to appeal a SEN decision'

  • Organise your appeal so that it will be easy for the panel to read and understand your key points.
  • Use paragraphs with headers and number your points, include a page which lists all your supporting documents (contents or appendices).
  • Within your appeal refer to evidence that backs up your points
  • Link your points to relevant law where you are able.
  • It can be helpful to write an opening summary or bullet point your key issues.
  • Remember the panel do not know your child, so make sure you include all their needs but...
  • Be as concise as you can, particularly with background history. Stick to needs that are still relevant.

Firstly, think about the reasons an assessment was requested in the first place. Key reasons usually fall into one or more of these categories:

  1. there are gaps in knowledge ie. it is not known what the needs are, and an assessment is the only way to determine these
  2. there is little or no progress* despite support from the setting
  3. the setting need help from the local authority to provide what is needed**

*progress is not limited to academic attainment and can be across any of the four broad areas of need (communication and interaction; cognition and learning; social, emotional and mental health difficulties; sensory and/or physical. See 6.28 to 6.34 of the SEND Code of Practice for a full definition)

**Read our information about Funding - settings can apply for top-up (high needs) funding without an EHC plan. You will need to consider how you can show the needs of your child are over and above what the setting can provide within the available funding.

With points 2 & 3 it will be essential to look at what the local authority expect schools and settings to provide, what is already being put in place, and what progress is being made.

You can find out what is generally available within the Suffolk Local Offer , but if you can't easily find what you need, you can request this with the local authority by letter or email.

Supporting evidence

Read the school's SEN policy, SEN Information report and accessibility plan (explains adjustments made for disabled pupils and ongoing plans to improve access). You can print off or screenshot anything that is relevant. If you can't find something you can request information from school - see also within appeal process dropdown.

You will need to clearly evidence educational needs. Though 'health' and 'care' needs are relevant and picked up within the EHC process, it is the educational needs that are the trigger for an assessment.

See below for some examples of supporting evidence...

  • Progress reports
  • IEP/support plan/pupil passport/provision map
  • Home/school diaries
  • Assesment/specialist reports
  • Exclusion letters/reports
  • Letters/emails from setting/local authority/health/specialist
  • Examples of school or homework (can be helpful where rate of progress is in dispute)
  • You can request a copy of your child's school record (you will likely be charged for photocopying)

Consider the local authority view

The decision letter from the local authority should explain why they decided not to carry out an EHC needs assessment.

They may have made other recommendations for example, a referral to a specialist service. You need to consider your counter-argument here as to why you believe this action will not meet your child's needs. 

Have the local authority taken everything into account? Read our information 'deciding whether to assess' or take a look at the SEND Code of Practice (9.14).

 

Consider the setting/school view

Where the setting were in support of the EHC needs assessment request, they are likely to be happy to share with you any supporting evidence, for example, a provision map outlining the planned support and related costs. They may also agree to provide a statement in support of your case.

What if school are not in support?

In this circumstance the local authority will be likely to include information from school as evidence for their case, so it is important to understand the arguments you will be up against.

Talk to school about why they do not feel an EHC needs assessment is required, and what their view is for next steps. Where they disagree about the rate of progress, use the opportunity to unpick this further..

Remember when we talk about progress this should not be limited to academic attainment, there may be wider needs which are having an impact to your child's learning.

Consider all your child's needs, what support they have had, for how long, and what impact (if any) the support has had ie. have the desired outcomes from targeted support been met?

Where the setting are suggesting trying a different strategy/service (and particularly where this was recommended by the local authority), consider how or whether this will have the desired impact for your child. For example, the strategy may have been tried previously or will only support one area of need whereas a full assessment will give you an overall picture.

  • The appeal will be registered by SEND Tribunals within 10 working days of receipt and they will write to you with the hearing date, and your deadline for submitting further documents or evidence. 
  • The local authority will receive a copy and will be given 30 working days to respond including whether they oppose the appeal.
  • Use this time to gather any further evidence. You can request information or a document from the local authority or school. If you can't get hold of information or a document important to your case, the SEND Tribunal has the power to make an order. Use their 'request for changes' form.
  • When you submit further documents or evidence* you must also send a copy to the local authority. Make sure you do this by the deadline as late evidence may not be accepted.
  • At least 10 working days before the hearing you will receive a copy of the full appeal bundle.
  • 'Refusal to assess' appeals are usually 'paper hearings' unless you request an oral hearing. A paper hearing means you will not need to attend.
  • The appeal will be considered by a panel - a tribunal judge and up to two specialist members,
  • The decision will be communicated with you (and the local authority), within 10 working days of the hearing.
  • If you win your appeal, the local authority must begin to carry out an education, health and care needs assessment within 4 weeks of the ruling.

*Use the appeal reference number in any correspondence with SEND Tribunals.

Download the SEND Tribunal guide 'How to appeal a SEN decision'

 

SEND Tribunal service (organisation responsible for handling appeals)

'How to appeal a SEN decision' guide (SEND tribunals)

IPSEA Refusal to assess pack (national charity providing legally based information, advice & support)

SEND Code of Practice 2015 (explains the statutory duties of schools and local authorities)

Suffolk Local Offer (where you can find out about the full range of services available locally for children with SEND)

Family Services Team (the local authority)

Anglia Care Trust (for mediation)